Nancy Eagleson Artwork

Missing Midwest

Missing Midwest is a true crime podcast telling the stories of those gone missing in the midwest region.

Missing Midwest

Nancy Eagleson

November 14, 2025 • Jonathan + Kayla Keith

Today’s story is a small town tragedy from 1960…but new developments in 2022 bring some potential clarity.

SOURCES

https://www.wtol.com/article/news/investigations/11-investigates/paulding-murder-investigation-missteps-mean-1962-nancy-eagleson-case-still-unsolved/512-a6c9eb2b-2708-4ca8-8a10-2009ebf2e740

https://uncovered.com/cases/nancy-eagleson

https://www.wtol.com/article/news/investigations/11-investigates/nancy-eagleson-cold-case-suspect-new-composite-sketch/512-1fe4d7e6-74d7-43f6-81f1-90e393bfae41