Consistently Candid

#13 Aaron Bergman and Max Alexander debate the Very Repugnant Conclusion

Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:53:51

In this episode, Aaron Bergman and Max Alexander are back to battle it out for the philosophy crown, while I (attempt to) moderate. They discuss the Very Repugnant Conclusion, which, in the words of Claude, "posits that a world with a vast population living lives barely worth living could be considered ethically inferior to a world with an even larger population, where most people have extremely high quality lives, but a significant minority endure extreme suffering." Listen to the end to hear my uninformed opinion on who's right.

Read Aaron's blog post on suffering-focused utilitarianism

Follow Aaron on Twitter
Follow Max on Twitter
My Twitter