Departed in Pennsyltucky
Departed in Pennsyltucky is a true-crime narrative podcast that takes you down the back roads of Pennsylvania, into small towns and forgotten headlines.
From unsolved disappearances to chilling murders, each episode uncovers the secrets still haunting the Keystone State.
Some stories were whispered for years. Others almost faded into obscurity—until now. True-crime talk without the valley-girl squawk.
Departed in Pennsyltucky
500 Miles for Murder, Part 1: The Case of Joann and Alex Katrinak
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On the afternoon of December 15, 1994, twenty-six-year-old Joann Katrinak was excited as she prepared to embark on a joyful shopping adventure for Christmas. She planned to take her four-month-old son, Alex, along with her mother-in-law, Veronica, as they searched for the perfect gifts. However, a wave of panic swept over the household when Joann's husband, Andy, returned home later that night, only to be silent and with an unsettling emptiness—there was no trace of his wife or their precious newborn son.
As the hours stretched into a tense night, suspicion inevitably settled on Andy. As the devoted spouse and father, he became the focal point of the investigation, his every action scrutinized by the police, who worked tirelessly to construct a case against him.
But just four months later, their investigation took a harrowing turn. The gruesome discovery of Joann and Alex's lifeless bodies, hidden away in a lonely stretch of woods, sent shockwaves through the community. The grim reality forced the police to shift their gaze and reconsider their assumptions, redirecting their efforts toward an entirely different suspect in this tragic case. Were Joann and baby Alex murdered by someone they didn't know? Or were they murdered by someone close to them who could not face reality?
